۱۳۸۷ اردیبهشت ۱۰, سه‌شنبه

ادامه بحث دستمال كاغذي!

ما ايراني ها به دستمال پارچه اي كه در سفره مي گذاريم مي گوييم دستمال سفره. اما به دستمال يك بار مصرف سرميز مي گوييم دستمال كاغذي. تنها وقتي اين دستمال كاغذي نقش و نگار خيلي جالب و زيبا داشته باشد آن را از مقام دست سفله"دستمال كاغذي" به مقام شامخ "دستمال سفره" ارتقا مي دهيم. اما" خارجي ها" مساوات را رعايت مي كنند و به هر دو ي اين ها
Napkinميگويند
جاي سفسطه بازان خالي ! اگر اينجا بودند بحث هاي شبه فلسفي راه مي انداختند و نتيجه مي گرفتندكه علت "ناكامي تاريخي" ما در همين است! من نمي خواهم آسمون ريسمون ببافم. فقط خواستم ياد آوري كنم دستمال كاغذي مورد نظر من
Napkin
است نه
tissue
به علاوه من معني آمريكايي اش را در نظر دارم نه "گلاب به رويتان" معني انگليسي اش را.
اما چند خاطره: تابستاني براي شركت در يك همايش به
Aspen
رفته بودم.
Aspen
منطقه زيبايي است. همايش هايي هم كه در اين شهر برگزار مي شوند استيل مخصوص به خود دارند. تمام تلاش بر اين است تا جو آرام و بدون تنش و غير رسمي باشد. ازجمله اين كه رئيس جلسه براي سمينارها تعيين نمي كنند. به تجربه دريافته اند در چنين جوي ايده هاي بيشتري متولد مي شوند. ايده يكي از مقاله هاي خودمن در جريان بحث در همين همايش شكل گرفت.
روزي در اين شهربا دوستان وهمكاران به يك كافي شاپ رفته بوديم. طبق معمول بحث فيزيك مي كرديم و احتياج به كاغذ شد. بازهم طبق معمول هيچكدام از ما فيزيكپيشگان كاغذ به همراه نداشتيم. دوستم سيلويا شروع به نوشتن روي دستمال كاغذي كرد. همسر يك از همكاران هم با ما بود . (زن و شوهر هر دو يهودي بودند! خانم هاي غير يهودي فيزيكپيشه ها كمتر تحمل بحث هاي بي سر وته ما رادارند و معمولا بحث را بر هم مي زنند!) وقتي صحنه را ديد از كيفش چند ورق كاغذ در آورد اما بقيه گفتند" ممنون اما تا روي دستمال ننويسيم" اصالت" نخواهد داشت.
در همايش
Moriond
كه همه ساله در كو ه هاي آلپ برگزار مي شود رسم بر اين است كه از شركت كنندگان براي بهتر برگزار شدن همايش در سال آتي نظر خواهي مي كنند.يادمه در اين جلسه يك آقاي ميانسال آمريكايي به عنوان انتقاد گفت
"مگر قرار نيست دستمال كاغذي سفيد باشد". تعجب كردم انتظار نداشتم يك مرد آمريكايي به رنگ دستمال توجه كرده باشد. با توضيحش متوجه ماجرا شدم:" وقتي روي دستمال آبي با خودكار آبي مي نويسيم چيزي معلوم نمي شود.

۱۳۸۷ اردیبهشت ۹, دوشنبه

Back-of-envelope calculation on napkin

در يكي از كوچه- پس- كوچه هاي نزديك پژوهشكده يك پيتزا فروشي دنج و آرام هست كه من و شاهين مشتريش هستيم. بيشتر مشتري هاي اين پيتزافروشي جوانان اهل محل هستند.جمع دوست داشتني اي دارد. يك طرف سالن قفسه كتاب گذاشته اند تا مشتري ها مطالعه كنند.معمولا موسيقي ملايمي پخش مي شود . برعكس غذاخوري هاي متعارف ايراني كه ملت زل مي زنند تا از همديگر ايراد بگيرند (مشتري هاي سنتي به نوعي- مشتري هاي آلا مد به نوعي ديگر) اينجا هر كسي سرش توي كار خودش است. نه كسي به ديگري ايراد مي گيرد كه چرا جوراب سفيد پوشيده و يا با دست پيتزا مي خوردو نه كسي از خوشي و سرزندگي ديگري غضبناك مي شود .... در اين پيتزا فروشي به جاي زل زدن و فضولي در كار ديگران
يكي كتاب مي خواند. ديگري با دوستانش شوخي و خنده مي كند (وكسي هم چپ چپ نگاهش نمي كند). نامزد ها با خلوت عاشقانه شان خوشندو... بالاخره در اين پيتزا فروشي مي توان نشست و بحث فيزيك كرد.

بعد از دو ماه اقامت در ايتاليا شديدا هوس پيتزاي پپروني وطني با سس كچاپ كرده بودم. همان طور ي كه احتمالا مي دانيد ايتاليايي ها اضافه كردن سس به پيتزا را توهين به آشپز مي دانند. به علاوه پپروني شان هم به جز چند تكه فلفل دلمه اي چيز ديگري ندارد. خلاصه نصف عمرشان بر فنا كه فرهنگ پيتزا يي هاي ايراني را ندارند.
خلاصه با شاهين به اين پيتزا فروشي رفتيم. شاهين ازمطالبي كه در كارگاه ونيز مطرح شده بود سئوال كرد و من شروع كردم به بازگويي آنچه كه مهم مي پنداشتم. چون قلم وكاغذ در دست نبود روي دستمال كاغذي
چند تا دياگرام كشيدم. استفاده از دستمال كاغذي در بحث هاي سر ميز بخشي از فرهنگ فيزيك است! به ظاهر چيز كوچكي است اما اشتراك در همين چيزهاي كوچك است كه احساس دوستي و نزديكي را مي سازد. بسياري از ايده هاي جالب روي همين دستمال كاغذي ها خلق شده اند. در نوشته بعدي ام چند تا خاطره دستمال كاغذيانه تعريف خواهم كرد.

۱۳۸۷ اردیبهشت ۲, دوشنبه

Ciao!

This is my last post from Italy. I will be back to Iran tomorrow after 61 days which passed just like 61 seconds. I enjoyed my stay a lot! When I was a student here for two years I did not enjoy it this much. Well, that is natural. I did not understand their culture back then as much as I understand it now. I was foolish enough to keep comparing Iran with Italy instead of relaxing and enjoying all the magnificent things that Italy has to offer to any one, Italian and non-Italian alike. The magnificent gifts of Italy include its beautiful nature, its rich cuisine, the friendliness of its people and their great sense of humor that never fails to entertain you, its long and fruitful history, its superb art, ... and its very very very rich research culture in high energy physics.
When I was a student I could not tell the difference between an excellent talk from a good one.Now that my background knowledge in physics has increased, I appreciate the difference. It is now that I enjoy the seminars I am attending in Italy. Now, I enjoy physics discussion at lunch and coffee tables. Back then I was just a listener ....
Dear Iranian physics students, If you happen to be visiting a country such as Italy my advice is that do not waste your time by comparing Iran with the country you are visiting, or talking about politics or.... Just mix up the physicists of that country and engage in physics discussions just in the same way that the best students of that country often do. Eventually, you will learn this culture and find it as one of the joys of your life as well as a way to fulfill your ambitions in your future career
By the way, I was at a meeting in Venice last week. At the last talk (which was given by Nobel laureate, Rubbia) I noticed someone vigorously typing on his laptop, I turned and found the famous Italian blogger, Dorigo. Here you can find his report of the event. I might write my version of the report later on.
Arrivederci!

۱۳۸۷ اردیبهشت ۱, یکشنبه

این مشکل ما نیست

برای ما فقط کمیت مهم است. فقط دوست داریم که شاخص‌ها را افزایش دهیم بدون اینکه بدانیم چطور باید اینکار را بکنیم. چرا، البته یک کار را خوب بلد هستیم. گوش پیچاندن. «شاخص را زیاد کن یا شاخصت می‌کنیم!» اگر مشکلی هم داری، این مشکل ما نیست.

در این دیار کسی به این توجه نمی‌کند که یک دانشگاه خوب استاد خوب دارد. یک دانشگاه خوب، دانشجویان دکتریش حقوق دریافت می‌کنند. یک دانشگاه خوب، مرکز مشاوره دارد تا در صورت بروز مشکل دانشجویان را راهنمایی کند و راههایی بهتر از خودکشی را پیش پای ایشان بگذارد، آنهم در جمع، آنهم در جلوی استاد و به نقلی به تحریک استاد. و خلاصه اینکه یک دانشگاه خوب، هزار و یک چیز خوب دیگر هم دارد ...

۱۳۸۷ فروردین ۳۱, شنبه

Altarelli's advice

Two years ago, I arranged for a round table discussion with the prominant physicists that were visiting us on the occasion of a meeting held by our institute on high energy phenomenology.
In the meeting Prof. Altarelli (a distinguished Italian professor who at the time was at CERN) emphasized over and over on the importance of expanding the relations with physicists around the world. Of course, I knew that scientific relations were instrumental for research and developing ideas but back then, I did not understand why he was emphasizing that much on this point.
Altarelli is a smart person and far more experienced than Monjoog. At one glance, he realized subtleties in the isolated physics community in Iran that took three years for naive
Monjoog to realize!
The story was that someone (I do not remember who) told me Altarelli would be interested in visiting Iran. Quite happily I sent him an email inviting him to participate and lecture in our school. He immidiately replied, thanked me for the invitation and asked about the background of the participants to prepare his lectures accordingly. This is the international norm! He came and gave very good lectures (as was expected from him) and after the school (without violating any deadline) he sent his follow-up paper for the proceedings. He, as well as other distinguished lecturers of the school, took our school very serious as they would have taken any school organized in a developed country. As a physicist he treated me as a younger colleague (as I expected him to do) without any arrogance but of course with respecting the due academic hierarchy. As a gentleman, he treated me with the same gallantry that he would have treated European young ladies. I remember that to arrange for listening the music performance by Shahin, a couple of students and I were arranging chairs. Once Altarelli saw this he stepped in and helped us with the chairs. That was while many young Iranian men present there did not bother to step in and watched Prof Altarelli (who was of their father's age) and the rest of us do the job! (Yes, a woman notices such gestures and never forgets!)
Now, about the subtleties that Prof. Altarelli saw in a "mud brick" that took me three years to see in a "mirror". It was the behavior of the so-called senior people. They were jumping up and down to show that Prof. Altarelli was their "Pesar Khaale". One of them who had not even participated in the school suddenly appeared and insisted on taking Altarelli to coffee. Altarelli did not know the guy. He was rather skeptical about him. He asked me if he was trustworthy!
Another one was killing himself to take the credit for inviting Altarelli to Iran....
Such a stupid behavior would not happen in a less isolated atmosphere! Altarelli was too polite and kind to point out his wonder at such manner but he was quite right in diagnosing the syndrome. He was right also about the prescription. We should expand our relations with the outside world. It will bring multi-facted benefits.

۱۳۸۷ فروردین ۲۴, شنبه

Another success story from Palo Alto garages

A while back, I had written a series of posts on the Stanfords. In one of the posts, I mentioned that after one century the university and its intellectual atmophere has inspired the people living close by so much that the area became a hub of creativity in many different subjects. For example, a company as successful as "google" was born in a modest garage at the small town (Palo Alto) where the Stanford Univ is located. Back then I was not aware that about 60 years earlier than the birth of "google", in another humble garage at Palo Alto, the Hewlett-Packard (HP) company was born.
To come over our traditional fatalistic outlook, let us read their success story which is accessable here.

۱۳۸۷ فروردین ۲۳, جمعه

Funny Higgs

To attract attention, some people try their sense of humor in choosing a title for their papers.Considering the fact that Higgs is the name of a mechansim and a hypothetic particle as well as the family name of a well-known physicist, it is a proper ingredient to make jokes. I earlier mentioned that there is a variant of Higgs model which is called "fat Higgs model". Now check this title
Prof. Higgs has written a paper with title
He has recently given an interview that is accessable here.